The trouble with audiophiles is that they tend to listen to the equipment, rather than the sound that the equipment produces. My 7.2 system sounds far better than my 2 channel system, at a huge cost in accuracy. It is set up so that if you are in the middle of a plane crash during a movie, you feel as though you are in the middle of a plane crash. When you apply that setup to music, you have a full, rich sound that is quite unlike anything that has ever been heard in a concert hall. My 2 channel system, by contrast, is set up so that I can't tell the difference between a single note played on a piano, and the same note played on a piano that is actually in the room. Deep, booming bass that terrifies the dog and results in a visit from the police is fun, but hardly realistic.
Another point about audiophiles is the concept of ABX testing. They will wax lyrical about this component over that one, the difference in sound that different cables make and so on, but when it comes to the good, old ABX test, they can become strangely quiet. This involves listening to component A, then to component B, then to component X which could be A or B. The subject has to decide which one, and the results can be startling, with performance remarkably close to pure coincidence in many cases.
I have Bach organ recordings that sound terrible, for the simple reason that they are pedal exercises recorded close to the organists sitting position. They are not intended to be musical. They are intended to show how hard the organist is working, with the result that you can hear the workings of the organ as much as you can hear the music that is being produced. It sounds like doors banging in a lunatic asylum. In reality, no recording of organ music would be miked that close to the organist, and you wouldn't hear the noise. You would hear the result of the noise, while the organist himself would probably be wearing earplugs.
So, when you audition a pair of headphones, whether you consider yourself to be an audiophile or not, the best advice is to buy what sounds good to you. Don't get hung up on what sounds good to someone else. If they don't like it, they can jump off the nearest cliff, because the whole point of using those earphones in the first place is so that a) other people don't have to hear your music, and b) you don't have to listen to them.