Otterbox Commuter vs. INCIPIO Silicrylic?

[JeremyV]

I have been looking for videos saying what one is better but i cant find any.. I wanna know what one is better and why. Ive used the commuter before and its nice but i wanna see what others think thanls

 

[mikinoz]

I have the Commuter for my 4s. Fits well, all functions accessible without removing from case (except a dock I imagine), protects brilliantly! I dropped the phone once onto a timber floor....not a mark! It's a little bulkier than some cases but not by much. Very happy.

 

[MauiWowwee]

I loved the commuter case up until a few days ago when the hard shell by the dock port cracked. I had a feeling that was going to happen since it seemed like a weak point when I first installed it. It got replaced yesterday by a speck candy shell flip case.

As for the incipio, I think that's the first case that I got but didn't like how flimsy the silicon was.

 

[kingnba6]

i love the otterbox. its the first thing i buy when i get a new phone. ive been using otterbox on my iphones since the 3g came out