Another Update!:  Charged my new 64gb black phone overnight to 100%.  It is still stock--have not restored from my backup of my 32gb 4S.  Pulled off charger at 4:30 this morning and as of 7:00 it is still showing 100%!. Have checked weather and sent 1 text.  WIFI ON, Cellular data ON, bluetooth ON, location services ON (but no apps installed), vibrate off (except silent mode), brightness 50% with auto dim on.  Now THIS is like the battery life I was getting on my 4, where it doesn't feel like simple standby is depleting the battery quickly.  I'll probably run this battery down to 1-5% (may take a couple days!) before restoring.  But I gotta say, now it doesn't feel like the phone/battery's fault.  Perhaps a rogue app from my 4 was depleting my 4S or I had a bad battery.  If I restore and it goes to $#!T I'll know.  More later, but for now, bueno!!