This is hard... I like both!
If I was to use a black or gold case I would use second one.
Pink blue purple etc cases the first one.
The cases I use basically help me pick a wallpaper
Now out of BOTH?? I think the first one is a tad nicer
Apple should be embarrassed with the stock selection of wallpapers that come with the iPhone. Could their selection be any lamer? Wallpaper at the iPhone's native screen resolution takes very little memory space.